This week, for the Cultish Creative Music Club, Frazer Rice pitched us "Opportunities (Let's Make Lots of Money)" by the Pet Shop Boys. Now, to be fair, he also pitched us a John Cougar Mellencamp song, and for a songs-that-describe-American-life assignment, picking a British group is... did we mention Frazer's a lawyer? He stretched our brains is what I'm trying to say. You'll want to hear our full conversation. I'll put that link below, but keep scrolling, because I have something else to share from my ensuing Pet Shop Boys rabbit hole.
When I hear the name Pet Shop Boys, the song that immediately gets stuck in my head is "West End Girls." I don't know why, exactly, or even how. Joseph referenced it as a roller skating jam and he might be right about that, but it's just in some corner of my brain, probably since the mid-80s when it was a hit. I've never thought much about it, and Frazer's pitch made for as good a time as ever to click around the internet about it.
First off, Neil Tennant (half of the Pet Shop Boys) met music legend Bobby Orlando (think Hi-NRG and disco) in New York in 1983, while Neil was interviewing Sting of all people. They hit it off and decided to make a record together.
Two influences are baked into what came next. Tennant had already written the rap part of the song on the floor of his London apartment, errr, flat, and if you dig around a little you can find he said he was completely inspired by "The Message" by Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five. And Bobby O programmed in the drums from Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean."
You want to get these in your ears. Do "Billie Jean" first, because the drums are going to be central to the next phase. Do "The Message" second, because the rapped story over the synths and that cinematic feel will play in next.
Bobby O really liked those "Billie Jean" drums. So much so that they became the backbone of the first version of "West End Girls," which came out in April 1984. This is not the hit version you and I know today, but the next thing you have to hear is this. It is crazy to know the influences and then hear this first pass at the idea.
"West End Girls" is "Billie Jean" and "The Message"! Who knew. Broken glass, everywhere.
That first version didn't take off in the UK, but the group still believed in the song. They cut their ties with Bobby O (he kept significant royalties on future sales), and in August 1985 they went back into the studio to re-record it with producer Stephen Hague. Tennant has said they told Hague they wanted it to sound filmic.
Hague slowed it down and gave it a slow build that added depth and made the song more foreboding. To my ear, that took it from less Michael Jackson and Grandmaster Flash to more British club sounding, and it turned into the hit song we know today.
Last but not least, we have to talk about the lyrics. First off, the song doesn't have a plot so much as it has voices floating in and out, describing feelings. That's important. Tennant took the approach from The Waste Land, which he calls "almost a sort of collage," saying that on this song "it's different voices."
On the completely literal side, it's a collage of contrasts. East End vs. West End is a class distinction, and Tennant described it as rough boys getting "a bit of posh," with the work/play angle in there too.
A bit of posh… oh, common people. Same class-crossing story, a decade earlier. The Pet Shop Boys were here first, haha.
The words are worth a straight read. The fingerprints of "The Message" are all over it, and there's even a breaking glass sound effect if you listen close, without it ever feeling like a Grandmaster Flash knockoff. I wouldn’t know the connection without the deep dive.
The foreboding, danceable, singalong vibes make it a perfect pop song. Cryptic in all the ways it is, but unique because of it, too. And with the Michael Jackson and Grandmaster Flash influences, plus the Bobby O sessions, it's got American fingerprints everywhere. Even the producer of the hit version, Stephen Hague, is an American.
And "Opportunities," the one Frazer pitched, came out of those same original sessions. It never got released with Bobby O either. It was redone for their first single on a new label, which Tennant has called a "total flop," then got reworked and re-released the next year, gaining greater popularity in the UK and US. Same sessions, same arc: a second take changed everything.
It's fun to find out where stuff comes from. The American connection is stronger than I would have imagined, and I'm as delighted as I am surprised by the depth in a dance track.
